7 Sweet Secrets That Make Red Rose Bakery Toms River NJ A Must-Visit Italian Destination In 2025
The buzz around Red Rose Bakery in Toms River, New Jersey, is stronger than ever, especially as we move through late 2025, solidifying its reputation as a premier destination for authentic, old-school Italian baked goods. Since its establishment, this family-owned gem has successfully carved out a loyal following by delivering a taste of Brooklyn and Jersey City's rich bakery traditions right to the Jersey Shore. Their commitment to quality and heritage is evident in every bite, from their signature Manicotti cookies to their elaborate, custom-designed cakes.
The original Red Rose Bakery location, situated in Rands Plaza on Hooper Avenue in Toms River, continues to thrive, serving as the flagship store for owners Joe Sernio and Walter McCloskey's vision. With recent expansions and a focus on modern convenience through delivery services like DoorDash and Uber Eats, the bakery ensures its fresh bread, decadent pastries, and famous butter cream cakes are accessible to all of Ocean County and beyond, proving that traditional recipes can meet contemporary demands.
The Founders and The Flourishing History of Red Rose Bakery
Red Rose Bakery is more than just a business; it is a tribute to family, tradition, and the enduring passion for Italian baking. The story begins in 2011 with a simple, heartfelt mission: to resurrect the classic, family-run Italian bakery experience.
- Founders: Joe Sernio and Walter McCloskey.
- Hometown Roots: Both Sernio and McCloskey were born and raised in Jersey City, New Jersey, bringing a deep-rooted understanding of classic urban Italian-American bakery culture to Toms River.
- The Name's Origin: The bakery is a namesake tribute to Walter McCloskey’s grandmother, Rose, honoring her legacy and influence on his baking career.
- Baking Pedigree: Walter McCloskey brought significant experience to the venture, having previously served as the head baker at the renowned Gian's Bakery. This background ensures the authenticity and quality of every recipe.
- Mission Statement: The founders’ goal is to bring back the "old school family-run Italian Bakery" concept, focusing on hard work, commitment, and pride in every product.
- Expansion: Starting in Toms River, the bakery has successfully expanded its footprint, opening a second location in Howell, NJ, and more recently, prepping for a third location in Asbury Park, catering to a wider New Jersey clientele.
This dedication to their roots is what sets the bakery apart. When customers bite into a Red Rose product, they are tasting a piece of the founders' history and the commitment of a truly family-owned business.
Decoding the Unforgettable Menu: Red Rose Bakery's Best Sellers and Italian Specialties
The heart of Red Rose Bakery’s appeal lies in its extensive menu, which perfectly balances classic Italian pastries with modern cake artistry. Their reputation is built on a few standout items that have become legendary in Ocean County and beyond.
The Iconic Italian Pastries and Cookies
For many patrons, a visit to Red Rose is incomplete without indulging in their signature Italian cookies and pastries. These items embody the "old school" tradition the bakery strives to maintain.
- Manicotti Cookies: Often cited by reviewers and the bakery itself as a must-try, the Manicotti cookie is a fan favorite, known for its unique texture and flavor profile.
- Casada Cream (Cannoli): Their Casada cream, a rich filling often used in cannoli, is another highly praised specialty. It’s a testament to their mastery of classic Italian dessert techniques.
- Fresh Bread: Beyond sweets, the bakery is well-known for its fresh-baked bread, a staple of any quality Italian establishment.
- Homemade Cheesecakes: Red Rose is recognized for making some of the best homemade cheesecakes in New Jersey, available at both their Toms River and Asbury Park locations.
Custom Cakes and The Famous Butter Cream
Red Rose Bakery has become a go-to for special occasion cakes, including elaborate wedding cakes and birthday creations. Their secret weapon is their superior butter cream.
They offer a wide array of cake flavors to suit any celebration or palate, ensuring every event, from a small birthday party to a grand wedding, has a memorable centerpiece.
- Butter Cream: They proudly claim to use the "best butter cream on their cakes," a key factor in their custom cake popularity.
- Popular Cake Flavors: The menu features classic and contemporary options, including: Mocha, Funfetti, Chocolate Tiramisu, Lemon, Lemon Raspberry, Red Velvet, Carrot, and Chocolate Strawberry.
- Elaborate Designs: Customers rely on Red Rose for elaborate, custom-designed cakes, showcasing the skill of their pastry chefs in cake artistry and decoration.
Why Red Rose Bakery is More Than Just a Local Bakery
The success of the Toms River institution extends beyond its quality products. It’s a blend of strategic business moves, community engagement, and a commitment to maintaining a high-profile presence in the competitive New Jersey bakery scene.
The "Taste of Brooklyn" Experience
The owners’ background and Walter McCloskey's experience at Gian's Bakery allow Red Rose to offer what many describe as a "taste of Brooklyn" right in the heart of Toms River. This cultural authenticity is a major draw for customers seeking the genuine flavors of a metropolitan Italian bakery without leaving the Jersey Shore.
Modernizing the Old-School Bakery
While the recipes are traditional, the business model is decidedly modern. The bakery has embraced technology and convenience to serve its expanding customer base.
- Delivery Services: Red Rose Bakery NJ is readily available for delivery through both DoorDash and Uber Eats, making it easy for residents of Toms River and surrounding areas to enjoy their treats at home.
- Online Presence: A strong online presence, including an active social media profile, keeps the community informed about new offerings and seasonal specialties.
A Celebrity Seal of Approval
The bakery has also gained notoriety through its association with high-profile figures in the baking world. They have hosted visits from notable personalities, including Buddy Valastro, the famous "Cake Boss," and Jay, further cementing their status as a destination bakery in New Jersey.
Navigating the Red Rose Experience: Tips for Your Visit in Toms River
Located conveniently in the Rands Plaza on Hooper Avenue, the Toms River location is the perfect starting point for your Red Rose journey. While the baked goods are consistently highly rated, customer service experiences can occasionally vary, as noted in some recent reviews.
To ensure the best possible experience, especially during peak holiday seasons or weekends, consider the following tips:
- Order Ahead: For custom cakes, large orders, or specific holiday items, calling ahead or ordering online is highly recommended to guarantee availability. The phone number for the Toms River location is readily available on their website.
- Try the Savory Items: Don't overlook the full menu. Red Rose Bakery also offers savory items like Garden Salads, Caesar Salads, and a variety of Paninis, making it a great stop for lunch as well as dessert.
- Visit Early: To get the freshest selection of bread and the full array of pastries, an early morning visit is often the best strategy.
- Explore the Locations: If you are traveling through the state, consider stopping at their other New Jersey locations in Howell and the upcoming Asbury Park shop to compare the experience.
Red Rose Bakery in Toms River stands as a testament to the power of traditional baking combined with modern business acumen. It continues to be a crucial part of the local culinary landscape, offering a sweet slice of Italian heritage to all of Ocean County. The hard work, commitment, and pride of the Sernio and McCloskey families ensure that the legacy of Rose will continue to flourish for years to come.
Detail Author:
- Name : Arvel Fadel
- Username : buster.erdman
- Email : isom29@stracke.net
- Birthdate : 1981-09-30
- Address : 53179 Raynor Creek Port Anabellefurt, VT 55070-9348
- Phone : 872-421-5095
- Company : Okuneva-Padberg
- Job : Education Teacher
- Bio : Quia maiores explicabo numquam delectus ut. Enim fuga vero dolores fugit. Delectus ipsa dolor esse eligendi perferendis officia esse. Quam tempore magni eum corporis dolore.
Socials
tiktok:
- url : https://tiktok.com/@marion_xx
- username : marion_xx
- bio : Nihil amet tempore beatae ipsum natus ut rerum.
- followers : 5366
- following : 1837
instagram:
- url : https://instagram.com/mhickle
- username : mhickle
- bio : Ut beatae vitae necessitatibus. Dicta aperiam dolorem corrupti quia quasi numquam sit.
- followers : 2405
- following : 2580
facebook:
- url : https://facebook.com/marion922
- username : marion922
- bio : Maxime iste et eos fugit iure natus eaque id. Dicta quod quod distinctio animi.
- followers : 811
- following : 1688
linkedin:
- url : https://linkedin.com/in/marion_official
- username : marion_official
- bio : Quia minima explicabo est et expedita aut.
- followers : 3518
- following : 2605
twitter:
- url : https://twitter.com/hicklem
- username : hicklem
- bio : Non eos ut expedita maiores sed corrupti animi. Et et omnis nobis optio eaque. Neque vel impedit nemo rerum.
- followers : 5419
- following : 2363
