7 Shocking Reasons Croxley's Ale House Farmingdale Is Long Island's Must-Visit Pub In 2025
Few Long Island establishments manage to balance a world-class craft beer selection with irresistible pub grub specials quite like Croxley's Ale House in Farmingdale. Situated right on Main Street, this outpost of the local alehouse chain has cemented its status as a premier destination for beer aficionados, sports fans, and anyone looking for a lively, laid-back atmosphere. It’s not just a bar; it’s a community hub that consistently delivers value and variety.
As of December 26, 2025, Croxley's Farmingdale continues its tradition of offering some of the best weekly deals and the most extensive draft list on the South Shore. From their famous 50-Cent Wing Nights to seasonal menu updates and a rotating selection of rare brews, the experience remains fresh and dynamic. If you're planning a trip to the heart of Farmingdale, knowing the ins and outs of this Ale House is essential for maximizing your visit.
The Ultimate Guide to Croxley's Farmingdale: Menu, Specials, and Atmosphere (2025 Update)
Croxley's Ale House is more than just a local watering hole; it is a full-service eatery and a destination for serious beer drinkers. Its location at 190 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735, places it right in the center of the village's vibrant downtown area, making it a convenient and popular spot for locals and visitors alike.
The core concept of Croxley's is simple but effective: a massive selection of craft beer paired with high-quality, approachable pub grub, all served in a casual, inviting setting. The atmosphere is laid-back and often buzzing, especially during major sporting events or their legendary special nights.
The Legendary 50-Cent Wing Night and Weekly Specials
The primary draw for many patrons are the incredible weekly specials that Croxley's has perfected. These deals are a staple of the Farmingdale location and a key reason for its enduring popularity.
- 50-Cent Wing Nights: This is arguably the most famous special. Patrons flock to the ale house for the chance to enjoy their signature wings at a fraction of the cost. The wings are available in various flavors and are a must-try.
- Taco Tuesday: A perfect mid-week treat, featuring $3 Tacos. This special offers a flavorful alternative to the typical pub fare and is a significant crowd-pleaser.
- Happy Hour: Croxley's Happy Hour is a consistent favorite for unwinding after work, offering deals on beverages and select appetizers.
- Croxley's Weekly Line Up: The establishment maintains a rotating schedule of events and promotions, ensuring there is always something happening, from trivia nights to game-day watch parties.
The consistency of these specials, even into the 2025 calendar year (as evidenced by promotions like the 2025 New Year's Party), shows the restaurant's commitment to providing value to the Long Island community.
The Unrivaled Beer Program: 59 Taps and Long Island Craft
For the true beer enthusiast, Croxley's Ale House is a pilgrimage site. The establishment proudly boasts one of the largest selections of craft beers in the region, solidifying its topical authority in the Long Island beer scene.
The beer menu is meticulously curated and incredibly extensive. It features a staggering 59 taps, supplemented by 29 bottles and 30 cans, ensuring a beer for every palate, preference, and occasion.
A Tour of the Croxley's Beer List Entities
The menu is categorized to help navigate the vast selection, which is a key feature that sets it apart from typical bars. Key categories and entities include:
- Rotating Rarities: This section is a constant source of excitement, featuring unique and often hard-to-find brews that rotate frequently.
- New & Seasonal: Highlights beers that are fresh to the market or perfectly suited for the current season, such as winter warmers or summer IPAs.
- Drink Long Island: A dedicated section that showcases local New York breweries, supporting the regional craft beer movement and offering a taste of Long Island's best.
- Essential Craft: The backbone of the menu, featuring reliable classics and must-try beers from established craft breweries.
- Style-Specific Sections: The menu is further broken down by style, including Pilsner, Light & Amber Lager, Wheat, and the ever-popular IPA, Pale & Amber categories.
Whether you're looking for a crisp Pilsner, a hoppy IPA, or a dark Stout, the sheer volume and variety of the draft menu at Croxley's Farmingdale make it a genuine ale house destination.
Seasonal and Signature Pub Grub: Beyond the Wings
While the beer and wing specials get most of the attention, the full menu at Croxley's is a robust offering of classic American pub grub and comfort food, with a focus on seasonal variety. The menu is structured to offer a complete dining experience, not just bar snacks.
The menu includes classic sections like Appetizers, Salads, Sandwiches, Burgers, and hearty Entrees/Tacos. Signature appetizers include the Fried Calamari with marinara, Spinach Dip & Chips, and the Jumbo Bavarian Pretzel served with spicy beer mustard.
Must-Try Seasonal Comfort Foods
To keep the menu fresh and appealing, Croxley's regularly introduces seasonal favorites. For the colder months, the menu often features comforting, substantial dishes, such as:
- Tomato Soup: A classic comfort dish, often served with a twist like Grilled Cheese Croutons.
- Buffalo Chicken Eggroll: A creative appetizer that merges pub flavors with a unique presentation.
- Chicken Pot Pie: A hearty entree featuring mixed veggies, a rich cream sauce, and freshly baked bread, perfect for a cold evening.
These seasonal additions, along with staples like their delicious burgers and fresh salads, ensure that Croxley's Ale House caters to all types of diners, from those seeking a quick bite to those looking for a full, satisfying meal.
A Community Hub: Events, Sports, and Farmingdale Vibe
Croxley's is deeply integrated into the Farmingdale community, serving as a social and entertainment focal point. It’s a place where people gather to watch major sports, celebrate holidays, and enjoy a vibrant local atmosphere.
The ale house is well-known for hosting watch parties for major sporting events, creating an electric atmosphere for fans. For instance, the venue was noted for being filled with fans during major golf tournaments like the Ryder Cup, demonstrating its role as a premier sports bar in the area. This community engagement is why Croxley's is frequently recognized in local guides, including being listed in the Bethpage Best of Long Island voters guide.
Whether you’re looking for a lively place to cheer on your team, a casual spot for a first date, or a venue for a large group gathering, Croxley's Ale House in Farmingdale provides a reliably excellent experience. Its combination of an expansive beer list, exceptional value-driven specials, and classic pub hospitality makes it a true Long Island staple.
Detail Author:
- Name : Hipolito Prohaska III
- Username : ludie.cremin
- Email : ghaag@langosh.com
- Birthdate : 1999-12-22
- Address : 65316 Durward Pike Suite 134 East Ivahfurt, MT 13157
- Phone : +1.443.269.5316
- Company : Moore-Hauck
- Job : Marketing VP
- Bio : Optio quia eos totam aliquid. Recusandae architecto tempore dolor quod doloremque. Laboriosam porro voluptas id minima aut adipisci. Vel qui qui animi nisi suscipit.
Socials
facebook:
- url : https://facebook.com/kirlin1970
- username : kirlin1970
- bio : Commodi non aliquid ratione quis facilis.
- followers : 1211
- following : 687
instagram:
- url : https://instagram.com/danika_dev
- username : danika_dev
- bio : Minima natus veritatis minus fugiat. Placeat et maiores corporis aut odio.
- followers : 4804
- following : 1304
