The $20 Bourbon That Crushes The Competition: An Expert Review Of Member's Mark Kentucky Straight Bourbon
The landscape of budget bourbon has been completely redefined by a store-brand whiskey that punches far above its weight class. As of late 2025, the Member's Mark Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey—an exclusive offering from Sam's Club—continues to be one of the most talked-about and highly-rated value pours on the market. Produced by the legendary Barton 1792 Distillery, this private-label spirit offers a classic, high-quality bourbon experience at an astonishingly low price point, often under $20 for the standard Small Batch expression. This deep-dive review explores the three main expressions that have made this the must-buy budget bottle of the year.
For savvy bourbon drinkers and cocktail enthusiasts alike, the question is simple: Is the Member's Mark Bourbon a genuine "hidden gem," or just another cheap mixer? The consensus among experts and consumers is overwhelmingly positive, citing its incredible flavor-to-price ratio and the pedigree of its producer, the Sazerac-owned Barton 1792 Distillery in Bardstown, Kentucky.
The Member's Mark Bourbon Portfolio: Small Batch, Single Barrel, and BiB
The Member's Mark line is not a one-trick pony; it offers three distinct Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey expressions, each providing a unique profile and proof level. All of these expressions are distilled and aged by the renowned Barton 1792 Distillery, a fact that immediately lends credibility and a certain flavor expectation to the brand.
Member's Mark Small Batch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
This is the workhorse of the lineup and the most widely available. It is the perfect entry point into the brand, offering incredible value for its price, which frequently sits under $20 for a 750ml bottle.
- Proof: 90 Proof (45% ABV)
- Age Statement: NAS (No Age Statement), but generally estimated to be around 4 years old.
- Tasting Profile: The Small Batch offers a classic, approachable bourbon profile. Reviewers consistently find notes of sweet caramel, brown sugar, vanilla, and a touch of oak. There are also hints of cinnamon and black pepper on the finish, likely due to Barton's undisclosed but widely accepted "high-rye" mash bill.
- Best Use: Due to its low price and 90 proof, this is the ultimate "utility bourbon." It is perfectly enjoyable neat or on the rocks, but truly shines as the base for classic cocktails like an Old Fashioned, Manhattan, or Whiskey Sour.
Member's Mark Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
For those looking for a more intense, full-bodied experience, the Single Barrel expression is a massive step up in flavor and proof, yet often only costs a few dollars more than the Small Batch.
- Proof: 110 Proof (55% ABV)
- Age Statement: NAS (No Age Statement).
- Tasting Profile: The higher proof brings a substantial punch of flavor. The palate is full-bodied, leading with intense sweet caramel, rich brown sugar, and toasted oak. Spice notes like cinnamon stick and nutmeg are prominent, often rounded out by unique notes of cherry cola and candied pecan.
- Best Use: This expression is highly recommended for sipping neat or with a single large ice cube. Its robust proof stands up beautifully to dilution, making it a favorite among enthusiasts who appreciate a higher-proof bourbon.
Member's Mark Bottled-in-Bond (BiB) Straight Whiskey
The Bottled-in-Bond (BiB) designation is a mark of quality and historical significance, governed by the 1897 Bottled-In-Bond Act. This expression adheres to strict regulations: it must be the product of a single distillation season, from a single distiller, aged for at least four years, and bottled at exactly 100 proof.
- Proof: 100 Proof (50% ABV)
- Age Statement: Minimum 4 years (required by BiB law).
- Tasting Profile: The BiB is often described as darker and richer than the Small Batch. The nose frequently reveals creamy caramel, deep vanilla, berries, and a strong presence of oak. The palate is powerful yet well-balanced, a testament to its consistent aging and proof.
- Best Use: The 100 proof is the "sweet spot" for many bourbon drinkers, providing enough heat for sipping while still mixing perfectly in cocktails. The BiB is often considered the best overall sipper in the Member's Mark lineup due to its richness and balance.
The Barton 1792 Connection: Why Member's Mark is a Steal
The single most important factor driving the quality and value of Member's Mark Bourbon is its producer: the Barton 1792 Distillery, which is owned by the Sazerac Company. Barton 1792 is responsible for well-known and highly-regarded brands such as 1792 Small Batch, 1792 Full Proof, and the legendary Thomas H. Handy Sazerac Rye. This association assures consumers that the bourbon is made with the same high standards and often the same high-rye mash bill used for their flagship products, though the exact recipe for the Member's Mark line remains proprietary.
The fact that a major Kentucky Straight Bourbon producer is willing to bottle a private-label product at such an aggressive price point—often $10 to $15 less than its own comparable 1792 Small Batch—is what makes Member's Mark a true "budget bourbon" phenomenon. You are essentially getting a quality, high-rye bourbon aged in new, charred oak barrels in Kentucky's climate, but without the marketing and distribution costs associated with a national brand. This is a classic example of a "distiller's secret" that has made its way to the mass market.
Member's Mark vs. The Competition: Kirkland and Beyond
The rise of high-quality, private-label spirits has created a new category of competition, often pitting warehouse clubs against each other. The Member's Mark Bourbon from Sam's Club is frequently compared head-to-head with its main rival, the Kirkland Signature Bourbon from Costco.
While both brands offer exceptional value, Member's Mark has a distinct advantage: a known, high-pedigree producer. While Kirkland's sourcing changes and is often shrouded in mystery, Member's Mark is consistently tied to Barton 1792. This gives the Sam's Club offering a reliable flavor profile and a level of consistency that is highly valued by bourbon drinkers.
In a direct comparison, reviewers often note that the Member's Mark expressions—especially the 110 Proof Single Barrel and the 100 Proof Bottled-in-Bond—offer a more complex and richer flavor than most competitors in the sub-$30 price bracket. The high-rye mash bill provides a welcome spice that elevates it beyond the simple sweet notes of many entry-level bourbons. The Small Batch, which scored an impressive 89 points out of 100 in a 2022 tasting, is considered a reliable, well-made spirit that competes directly with upper-middle-end bourbons.
Final Verdict: The Best Value Bourbon on the Shelf Today
The Member's Mark Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey line is not merely a good budget bourbon; it is a phenomenal value proposition that continues to impress critics and consumers alike in 2025. Whether you choose the versatile 90-proof Small Batch for your mixed drinks, the high-octane 110-proof Single Barrel for sipping, or the perfectly balanced 100-proof Bottled-in-Bond, you are getting a product distilled by one of the most respected names in the industry.
For a reliable, high-quality, and budget-friendly addition to your liquor cabinet, you simply cannot do better than the Member's Mark line. It is the definitive answer to the question of where to find the best bourbon bargain, solidifying its status as a must-buy Sam's Club exclusive.
Detail Author:
- Name : Delta Howe
- Username : treinger
- Email : treva.kirlin@becker.com
- Birthdate : 1996-03-05
- Address : 666 Reichel Viaduct Harmonfort, CT 20491
- Phone : 1-425-519-7007
- Company : Mertz, Renner and Halvorson
- Job : Financial Examiner
- Bio : Dolores iste sed repudiandae dolorem. Tempora non odio accusantium laudantium maiores sint enim itaque. Et et eius quo. Ducimus et quod est qui deleniti id.
Socials
facebook:
- url : https://facebook.com/eboehm
- username : eboehm
- bio : Consequatur nulla tempore et delectus. Dolorum vitae nisi commodi qui numquam.
- followers : 4067
- following : 2424
tiktok:
- url : https://tiktok.com/@eldridge_boehm
- username : eldridge_boehm
- bio : Quod adipisci natus veritatis dolorem voluptates. Id odio quod voluptates iure.
- followers : 3065
- following : 1977
