Home International Buzz

5 Reasons Why Gold & Meyer's Deli In Plainview Is A Long Island Tradition Since 1959

• minute read
Contents

Gold & Meyer's Gourmet Deli in Plainview, New York, is far more than just a place to grab a quick sandwich; it is a true Long Island institution with a history stretching back over six decades. As of December 2025, this deli and bagelry continues to thrive as a neighborhood destination, celebrated for its massive portions, fresh-baked goods, and commitment to the classic New York deli experience. The Plainview location, situated on Old Country Road, remains a cornerstone of the community, consistently earning high praise for its quality and service.

The deli’s enduring popularity stems from its ability to blend the traditional Jewish deli menu—think towering sandwiches and fresh bagels—with modern gourmet offerings and an extensive catering service. Whether you're a long-time Plainview resident or a first-time visitor, understanding what makes Gold & Meyer’s a local legend is key to fully appreciating this Long Island staple.

A Plainview Tradition: History and Locations of Gold & Meyer's

The story of Gold & Meyer's Gourmet Deli & Bagelry is rooted deep in the history of Plainview, New York. The original establishment was founded in Plainview in 1959, establishing it as a culinary landmark long before many of its modern competitors even existed. This long-standing presence means the deli has been a part of generations of local lives, serving as a reliable spot for everything from Sunday breakfast to holiday catering.

Over the years, the business has only grown stronger, becoming a genuine Plainview tradition. The success of the original location at 1036 Old Country Rd, Plainview, NY 11803 led to expansion, and today, Gold & Meyer's also operates a second popular spot in Farmingdale, New York, located at 255 Airport Plaza Blvd. This two-location model allows them to serve an even wider area of Long Island, bringing their signature deli meats and fresh bagels to a broader audience.

The deli is often praised for its authentic atmosphere and the passion of its staff. The current owners' connection to the business is deep, with their journey having begun within the establishment itself, a testament to the dedication to maintaining the deli's high standards and community focus.

The 5 Must-Try Menu Items That Define Gold & Meyer's Deli

The menu at Gold & Meyer's is extensive, covering everything from morning coffee and bagels to full lunch platters and dinner appetizers. However, a few items stand out as true local favorites and must-tries for anyone visiting the Plainview location. These signature dishes are what drive the deli's reputation for quality and flavor.

1. The Legendary Pastrami King

No discussion of a classic New York-style deli is complete without mentioning the pastrami, and Gold & Meyer's delivers with its Pastrami King. This signature sandwich is a monumental stack of hot, thinly sliced pastrami, often served on rye bread, embodying the quintessential deli experience. At a price point that reflects its generous size, the Pastrami King is a top-tier choice for serious deli enthusiasts looking for an authentic taste of Long Island.

2. The "Best Bagels" on Long Island

For many locals, the true star of the show is the bagel. Gold & Meyer's is proudly a Bagelry, baking their bagels fresh daily. The local buzz is intense, with some patrons on social media claiming they are the "best bagels" they have ever eaten. Whether you prefer a plain bagel with butter, a bagel with a gourmet spread, or a hearty Breakfast Sandwich with egg and cheese, the quality of the dough and the fresh bake are undeniable.

3. The Monte Cristo Sandwich

A more unique and gourmet option on the menu is the Monte Cristo sandwich. This classic sandwich, typically featuring ham, turkey, and Swiss cheese on French toast bread, is a decadent choice that sets Gold & Meyer's apart from standard delis. It highlights the deli's willingness to offer more than just cold cuts, catering to a diverse palate.

4. The Big BBQ and Veggie Delight

The menu also caters to a range of dietary preferences with two other prominent signature sandwiches: the Big BBQ and the Veggie Delight. The Big BBQ is a savory, meat-forward option, while the Veggie Delight ensures that those looking for a fresh, tailor-made salad or a non-meat option have an excellent, flavorful choice. The availability of tailor-made salads and a full selection of deli meats like Roast Beef and Turkey ensures every customer finds their perfect meal.

5. Unexpected Italian Appetizers

What surprises many first-time visitors is the inclusion of Italian-style appetizers, showcasing the deli's "Gourmet" title. The menu often features items like Baked Clams Oreganata, Fried Calamari, Stuffed Mushrooms, and Shrimp Cocktail. This diverse selection makes Gold & Meyer's a one-stop-shop for a full meal, not just a quick sandwich stop, providing high-quality catering options for events and parties.

The Gold & Meyer's Experience in the Modern Era (2024 Updates)

Despite its rich history dating back to 1959, Gold & Meyer's Deli remains current and competitive in the modern Long Island food scene. The Plainview location, specifically at 1036 Old Country Rd, continues to be a hub of activity, adapting to contemporary customer needs and technology.

Comprehensive Catering and Community Service

The deli is a powerhouse in the local catering market, providing comprehensive services for both business and personal events. Their offerings include everything from large Breakfast Platters and Bagel assortments to full deli spreads and boxed lunches. This focus on high-quality, large-scale food preparation solidifies its role as a key community partner for Plainview and surrounding areas.

Digital Accessibility and Delivery Services

In the age of instant gratification, Gold & Meyer's ensures convenience through multiple online ordering and delivery platforms. Customers can easily order their favorite items—from a Half Dozen bagels to the Pastrami King—via major services like Grubhub, Seamless, and DoorDash. This digital presence has helped the deli maintain strong customer engagement, as evidenced by recent reviews from 2024 and even menu updates for December 2025.

A Hub for Breakfast and Lunch

While the deli is open for lunch and dinner, it is arguably most famous as a destination for breakfast. The aroma of freshly baked bagels and brewing coffee draws in a constant stream of customers every morning. The menu’s focus on hearty morning options, including various Breakfast Sandwiches, Oatmeal, and the classic Cheese Omelet, ensures that it remains the top choice for Plainview commuters and families alike.

In conclusion, Gold & Meyer's Gourmet Deli in Plainview is a testament to the enduring appeal of a classic Long Island deli. Its 1959 founding, coupled with a modern menu that features legendary sandwiches like the Pastrami King and the highly-praised bagels, ensures its status as a beloved institution. It’s a must-visit for anyone seeking authentic, high-quality deli fare in New York.

5 Reasons Why Gold & Meyer's Deli in Plainview is a Long Island Tradition Since 1959
gold and meyers deli plainview
gold and meyers deli plainview

Detail Author:

  • Name : Sigrid Skiles
  • Username : myrl70
  • Email : zhansen@oconnell.com
  • Birthdate : 1997-08-15
  • Address : 6021 Imogene Manor South Mohammed, AK 22487
  • Phone : 279-725-1325
  • Company : McClure, Gislason and Nicolas
  • Job : Coaches and Scout
  • Bio : Id veritatis quis velit facilis. Voluptatem id molestiae dignissimos neque. Excepturi magni dignissimos laboriosam eos ea. Aspernatur non quo quod ut veniam asperiores.

Socials

tiktok:

twitter:

  • url : https://twitter.com/mcdermotte
  • username : mcdermotte
  • bio : Et minus ad quis iste. Debitis velit blanditiis est. Eos cum sed quo. Eos a et accusantium deleniti consequatur dolorem est.
  • followers : 3530
  • following : 2400

instagram:

  • url : https://instagram.com/emmymcdermott
  • username : emmymcdermott
  • bio : Enim ipsam unde repellat at. Voluptatem qui possimus et ex. Et necessitatibus et est fugiat.
  • followers : 1014
  • following : 910

linkedin:

facebook:

Random Posts