The Unstoppable Black Cap Brewing Company: 5 Facts About Its Resilient History And Must-Try Beers In 2025
Despite persistent rumors and reports of closure, Black Cap Brewing Company in Red Lion, PA, continues to be a resilient force in the Pennsylvania craft beer scene. As of late December 2025, the brewery maintains an active physical presence, a dedicated beer menu, and a loyal following, showcasing a history marked by unexpected shutdowns and triumphant re-openings. This article delves into the full, complex story of Black Cap, clarifying its current status, celebrating its co-owners' vision, and highlighting the acclaimed brews that keep beer enthusiasts returning to York County.
The journey of Black Cap Brewing is a testament to the passion and tenacity required to thrive in the competitive craft beverage industry. From its initial location in a historic building to its current home in a modern mixed-use development, the brewery has navigated significant challenges, including a forced closure and persistent 'out of business' listings. We explore the facts behind the rumors, the signature beers that define their style, and exactly where you can find the current taproom today.
The Resilient History of Black Cap Brewing: Greg Bentley, Jim Waller, and the Red Lion Revival
The dream of Black Cap Brewing Company was founded by co-owners Greg Bentley and Jim Waller, two individuals who shared a strong desire to bring fresh, hand-crafted beer to the Red Lion area of York County, Pennsylvania.
The First Iteration and Forced Closure
Black Cap Brewing first opened its doors at a beloved location, originally situated in the old post office on the corner of High Street and North Main. This initial taproom quickly became a local favorite, establishing a reputation for quality craft beer and a welcoming atmosphere.
However, the brewery faced a critical challenge only a few years after opening. Co-owner Greg Bentley was presented with a difficult choice: either purchase the building or end the lease. Unable to secure the property, Black Cap was forced to sell its assets and close down, a decision that left the Red Lion community without its local brewery for a period.
The Triumphant Re-Opening and Current Status
The story did not end there. Driven by their original vision, Bentley and Waller successfully resurrected Black Cap Brewing Company in a new, more stable location. The current taproom is situated at 252 North Franklin Street in Red Lion, PA 17356. This new site is uniquely located on-site at the Red Lion Table Company Apartments, bringing high-quality food and craft beer to a relaxed, modern setting.
Despite being listed as "Out of Business" or "Permanently closed" by some industry trackers, the brewery's own website lists current hours of operation (typically Tuesday through Thursday, 4–9 pm), and its Untappd profile shows recent check-ins by patrons, confirming its operational status as of late 2025.
A Deep Dive into Black Cap’s Signature Craft Beer Menu
Black Cap Brewing Company has built its topical authority on a diverse and well-rated selection of handcrafted beers, catering to a wide range of palates from hop enthusiasts to those who prefer classic European styles. Their commitment to quality is evident in the consistent ratings and enthusiastic reviews on platforms like Untappd.
Notable and Highly-Rated Brews (LSI Entities):
- Hop Scramble (IPA - American): A staple for hop lovers, this American IPA is frequently checked in and highly regarded for its balance and flavor profile.
- General Gates Porter (Porter - Other): A darker, malt-forward offering that provides a rich and satisfying experience, often praised for its smooth finish.
- The Golden Abbey (Belgian Strong Golden Ale): Achieving a solid rating of 3.8 out of 5, this Belgian-style ale showcases the brewery’s versatility beyond standard American styles.
- Helles Bock (Lager - Other): Another high-scoring brew with a 3.8 rating, demonstrating Black Cap’s mastery of clean, crisp lager production.
- Going Postal DIPA: A recent entry that has seen check-ins, indicating a commitment to producing bolder, double-hopped varieties.
- Pumpkin Cream Porter: A seasonal favorite, this brew highlights the creativity of the brewers in incorporating unique flavors.
- Red Pants IPA: Another American IPA that has become a recognizable name on the tap list.
- Oktoberfest (Märzen): A seasonal German-style lager that is a must-try during the fall months.
The brewery’s commitment extends to traditional styles such as their Cream Ale and Golden Lagerbier, ensuring there is a brew for every preference. The variety of styles—from light lagers to strong porters and double IPAs—establishes Black Cap as a well-rounded and sophisticated craft brewery.
Visiting the Current Black Cap Taproom in Red Lion, PA
The current location at 252 North Franklin Street provides a relaxed and modern setting for patrons to enjoy their craft beer. The taproom is a central part of the Red Lion Table Company Apartments development, contributing to the local community's revitalization efforts.
Taproom Details and Amenities:
The brewery is known for offering a high-quality food menu alongside its craft beer, making it a true brewpub experience. Visitors can expect more than just a place to drink; it is a destination for a full dining and social outing.
Parking is convenient, with private parking available in the stone lot off Franklin Street and additional paved parking on Cypress Lane. The relaxed atmosphere and focus on community engagement have made the new location a successful continuation of the founders' original vision.
Essential Visitor Information:
- Address: 252 North Franklin Street, Red Lion, PA 17356.
- Phone Number: 717-417-6742.
- Current Hours: Typically Tuesday - Thursday: 4-9pm (Note: Hours are subject to change, so checking their official channels is always recommended).
- Key Entities: Red Lion Table Company Apartments, Cypress Lane, North Franklin Street, York County.
The Future of Craft Beer in York County and Black Cap’s Role
Black Cap Brewing Company's story is a powerful narrative of persistence in the face of business adversity. The initial closure, often cited in older articles, led to a stronger, more permanent establishment that continues to serve the Red Lion area. The co-owners, Greg Bentley and Jim Waller, have demonstrated an unwavering commitment to their craft and their community.
The brewery's diverse beer list, which includes everything from the robust General Gates Porter to the bright Helles Bock, ensures its relevance in the ever-evolving craft beer market. By maintaining a strong local presence and consistently producing high-quality brews, Black Cap Brewing Company has cemented its status as a cornerstone of the York County craft scene, proving that even after a setback, a great beer dream can be successfully revived.
Detail Author:
- Name : Mr. Ryleigh Reichert
- Username : amanda.hettinger
- Email : altenwerth.boyd@yahoo.com
- Birthdate : 1999-04-30
- Address : 12936 Elnora Springs East Ollie, ND 53049-1065
- Phone : +1 (520) 761-2435
- Company : Green-Lakin
- Job : Nonfarm Animal Caretaker
- Bio : Provident esse quo consequatur consequatur blanditiis. Optio labore voluptatum tenetur voluptatum nisi eos et et. Deserunt tenetur nobis labore optio distinctio voluptatem.
Socials
facebook:
- url : https://facebook.com/nhessel
- username : nhessel
- bio : Est pariatur et iure id inventore et. Dignissimos magnam natus dolorem qui.
- followers : 1476
- following : 2029
tiktok:
- url : https://tiktok.com/@hessel1970
- username : hessel1970
- bio : Amet omnis voluptatum corporis velit eaque.
- followers : 338
- following : 2212
