5 Secrets Behind Early Bird Farmhand's Choice Granola: Why It's Consumer Reports' Top Pick

Contents

As of December 2025, the world of gourmet breakfast foods is dominated by a few standout products, but none have captured the attention and high praise quite like Early Bird Farmhand's Choice Granola. This "delicious utilitarian choice" has transcended the crowded granola market, not just for its satisfyingly salty-sweet crunch, but for the integrity of its small-batch production and high-quality, simple ingredients. It’s a favorite of discerning palates, including culinary icon Martha Stewart, and has been consistently recognized for its exceptional flavor profile.

The secret to its success isn't a complex, proprietary blend, but rather an authentic, back-to-basics approach that utilizes the three most integral ingredients at a cook's disposal. This article dives deep into the Brooklyn-born brand's philosophy, the unique elements that make the Farmhand's Choice recipe a top seller, and why it recently earned the highest taste score from Consumer Reports, solidifying its status as a must-have pantry staple for a healthy breakfast option.

The Artisan Behind the Brand: Early Bird Foods & Co. Biography

The story of Early Bird Foods & Co. is a testament to the power of simple, high-quality ingredients and a clear vision. The company's origins date back to 2008 in Brooklyn, New York, where founder Nekisia Davis first created the Farmhand's Choice recipe.

  • Founder: Nekisia Davis
  • Founded: 2008
  • Location: Brooklyn, New York
  • Company Status: Woman-owned and LGBTQ+-Owned.
  • Product Philosophy: To dish out wholesome sweet & salty goodness by baking granola in tiny batches.
  • Key Recognition: Featured in The New York Times, favorite of Martha Stewart, and consistently high-rated in taste tests.
  • Product Commitment: All granola is naturally gluten-free and vegan, catering to a wide range of dietary needs.

Davis's original creation, the Farmhand's Choice, quickly became the company's best seller and original recipe, setting the standard for what gourmet granola should taste like. The brand's commitment to small-batch production and using real, discernible ingredients has been the cornerstone of its success, appealing to consumers looking for authentic, delicious, and healthy food. The brand's ethical and quality-focused approach has established Early Bird Foods & Co. as a leader in the artisanal snack market.

1. The Unconventional Ingredient That Creates the Perfect Crunch

Most commercial granola brands rely on vegetable or canola oil to achieve their signature crunch and texture. Early Bird Farmhand's Choice, however, takes a decidedly more gourmet and flavorful route by using extra-virgin olive oil. This is perhaps the most distinctive element of the Farmhand's Choice recipe, moving it far beyond the realm of standard rolled oats and nuts blends.

The use of extra-virgin olive oil contributes a subtle, savory depth that perfectly balances the sweetness of the maple syrup and brown sugar. This savory-sweet profile is what reviewers often point to as the reason for its addictive quality. The oil not only binds the organic rolled oats, organic coconut, and various seeds together but also ensures a delicate, crisp texture that avoids the overly hard or dry consistency found in many mass-produced granolas. It's a culinary choice that speaks to the brand's commitment to flavor complexity and quality fat sources, making it a truly unique breakfast choice.

Other key components in this unique blend include:

  • Organic Pumpkin Seeds
  • Organic Sunflower Seeds
  • Hand-selected Fancy Pecans
  • Real Maple Syrup
  • Organic Brown Sugar

This combination of high-quality nuts, seeds, and oils is what helps the granola achieve its low sugar content relative to many competitors. At around 5.3g of sugar, it’s positioned as a healthier alternative, proving that a delicious utilitarian choice doesn't have to be a sugary one.

2. A Flavor Profile That Earned the Highest Taste Score

The ultimate measure of any food product is its taste, and the Farmhand's Choice Granola has repeatedly proven its superiority. In a major taste-test of over 28 brands, Early Bird Farmhand’s Choice Granola stood out. Most notably, a recent in-depth analysis of 40+ brands featured in a July 2024 Consumer Reports issue awarded Early Bird Farmhand’s Choice the highest taste score. This is a significant endorsement that separates it from the competition.

The flavor is often described as "salty & sweet," a perfect harmony that prevents the palate fatigue common with overly sugary granolas. The hand-selected pecans are a highlight, providing a buttery, rich crunch that complements the earthy notes of the organic seeds. For those who appreciate gourmet granola, the subtle hint of real maple syrup offers a natural sweetness that feels authentic and less processed than corn syrup or artificial sweeteners.

This commitment to a balanced, sophisticated flavor is what has made it a long-time favorite among culinary professionals and health-conscious consumers alike. It is a product that can be enjoyed in various ways:

  • As a topping for Greek yogurt or skyr.
  • Mixed with fresh fruit as a morning parfait.
  • Eaten straight out of the bag as a high-energy snack.
  • Sprinkled over ice cream or baked goods for added texture.

3. Catering to Modern Dietary Needs: Vegan and Gluten-Free

In today's market, a premium product must be both delicious and accommodating to common dietary restrictions. Early Bird Foods & Co. has ensured that Farmhand's Choice Granola meets these modern demands by being both vegan and gluten-free. This dual certification significantly broadens its appeal, allowing individuals with celiac disease, gluten sensitivities, or those following a plant-based diet to enjoy a high-quality, artisanal breakfast.

The use of rolled oats is common, but ensuring they are certified gluten-free is a critical step that the company takes to maintain product integrity. Furthermore, the sweetness comes entirely from real maple syrup and organic brown sugar, avoiding any animal-derived ingredients, thus securing its vegan status. This dedication to clean, inclusive ingredients is a major factor in the brand's growing topical authority and consumer trust.

While the granola is generally a healthy breakfast choice, consumers should be mindful of the portion size, as with any high-quality, calorie-dense food. A typical serving size can range, but the delicious nature of the product makes it easy to consume more. However, its high content of healthy fats (from the pecans, seeds, and olive oil) and fiber makes it a satisfying and energy-sustaining option for a busy morning, living up to its name as the "Farmhand's Choice."

5 Secrets Behind Early Bird Farmhand's Choice Granola: Why It's Consumer Reports' Top Pick
early bird farmhand's choice granola
early bird farmhand's choice granola

Detail Author:

  • Name : Sigrid Skiles
  • Username : myrl70
  • Email : zhansen@oconnell.com
  • Birthdate : 1997-08-15
  • Address : 6021 Imogene Manor South Mohammed, AK 22487
  • Phone : 279-725-1325
  • Company : McClure, Gislason and Nicolas
  • Job : Coaches and Scout
  • Bio : Id veritatis quis velit facilis. Voluptatem id molestiae dignissimos neque. Excepturi magni dignissimos laboriosam eos ea. Aspernatur non quo quod ut veniam asperiores.

Socials

tiktok:

twitter:

  • url : https://twitter.com/mcdermotte
  • username : mcdermotte
  • bio : Et minus ad quis iste. Debitis velit blanditiis est. Eos cum sed quo. Eos a et accusantium deleniti consequatur dolorem est.
  • followers : 3530
  • following : 2400

instagram:

  • url : https://instagram.com/emmymcdermott
  • username : emmymcdermott
  • bio : Enim ipsam unde repellat at. Voluptatem qui possimus et ex. Et necessitatibus et est fugiat.
  • followers : 1014
  • following : 910

linkedin:

facebook: